How to Spot a Purebred Kitten Scam
Kitten scams are more common than you think — and they target people who just want a loving pet. Here are the red flags every buyer should know before sending a single dollar.
It is a heartbreaking scenario that plays out thousands of times every year. Someone falls in love with photos of an adorable Ragdoll or Maine Coon kitten online, sends a deposit — sometimes hundreds of dollars — and then the "breeder" disappears. No kitten. No refund. Just silence.
Purebred kitten scams are rampant, and they are getting more sophisticated. Scammers use stolen photos, fake websites, and convincing stories to prey on people who simply want a loving companion. At Cowgirl Cattery, we want to help you protect yourself. Here are the red flags to watch for before you hand over a single dollar.
Red Flag #1: The Price Is Too Good to Be True
Purebred kittens from reputable breeders cost money — and for good reason. Health testing, quality nutrition, veterinary care, and responsible breeding practices all add up. A genuine Ragdoll or Maine Coon kitten from a health-tested breeding program typically costs between $1,200 and $2,500 or more depending on the breeder and bloodlines.
If you see a purebred kitten listed for $300, $400, or even $600, be very suspicious. Scammers use artificially low prices to attract buyers quickly. The "deal" is the hook — and once you are emotionally attached to the photos, they start adding fees.
Red Flag #2: Requests for Unusual Payment Methods
Legitimate breeders accept standard payment methods — Venmo, Zelle, PayPal, credit card, or bank transfer. Scammers almost always insist on payment methods that are difficult or impossible to reverse:
- Gift cards (iTunes, Google Play, Amazon) — no legitimate breeder will ever ask for this
- Wire transfers to overseas accounts
- Cryptocurrency with no other payment option offered
- Cash by mail
If a breeder insists on one of these methods and refuses alternatives, walk away immediately.
Red Flag #3: No Video Call or Live Photos
In the age of smartphones, there is no reason a legitimate breeder cannot hop on a quick video call to show you the kitten in real time. Scammers rely on stolen photos — often taken from real breeders' websites or social media — and cannot produce a live video of the kitten because it does not exist.
Before committing to any deposit, always ask for:
- A live video call showing the kitten and the home environment
- A photo of the kitten next to a handwritten note with your name and the date
- Video of the kitten interacting with the breeder
A reputable breeder will be happy to do this. A scammer will make excuses.
Red Flag #4: The Kitten Is Available for Immediate Shipping
Responsible breeders do not ship kittens like packages. Kittens need to stay with their mother until at least 12 weeks of age — ideally longer — for proper socialization and immune development. A breeder offering to ship a kitten immediately, or within days, is a serious red flag.
Additionally, reputable breeders typically have waitlists. If a breeder has a perfect purebred kitten available right now with no wait, no application process, and no questions asked, that should raise your suspicion.
Red Flag #5: Escalating Fees After the Initial Payment
This is one of the most common scam tactics. You pay a deposit, then the scammer invents additional charges:
- "Shipping insurance" fees
- "Customs clearance" fees for international shipping
- "Crate and travel" fees
- "Vaccination certificate" fees
- "Temperature-controlled transport" fees
Each time you pay, a new fee appears. The kitten never arrives. Legitimate breeders are upfront about all costs from the beginning — there are no surprise fees after you have already paid.
Red Flag #6: No Physical Address or Verifiable Location
A legitimate cattery has a real address. Reputable breeders are usually happy to have you visit in person, or at minimum can verify their location through their TICA registration, social media history, or references from past buyers.
Scammers are vague about location — they may claim to be "nearby" but never commit to an address, or they claim to be overseas and offer shipping as the only option. Always ask for a physical address and verify it exists.
Red Flag #7: No Registration Papers or Health Records
As we covered in our post on TICA registration, a legitimate purebred kitten should come with documentation. If a breeder cannot provide:
- TICA or CFA registration papers
- Health records and vaccination history
- A written health guarantee
...that is a major warning sign. Scammers cannot produce real registration papers because their kittens are not registered — or do not exist at all.
Red Flag #8: Pressure to Decide Quickly
"Someone else is interested and will take the kitten if you don't pay today." Sound familiar? This is a classic high-pressure sales tactic designed to make you act before you have time to think or do research.
Reputable breeders want you to be sure. They will answer your questions, let you take time to decide, and never pressure you into a rushed decision. If you feel pressured, that is a red flag.
Red Flag #9: The Website or Social Media Looks Off
Scam operations often have telltale signs if you look closely:
- Stock photos that appear on multiple websites (do a reverse image search on Google)
- Recently created social media accounts with few followers and no history
- Generic website templates with no real information about the breeder's history or program
- Testimonials that cannot be verified — no last names, no photos, no way to contact past buyers
- Copied content from other legitimate breeder websites
Do a reverse image search on any kitten photos you see. If those same photos appear on multiple websites under different breeder names, you are looking at a scam.
How to Verify a Legitimate Breeder
Here is what to look for when vetting a breeder:
- Check TICA's breeder directory at tica.org — registered breeders are listed there
- Ask for references from past buyers and actually contact them
- Request a video call before any money changes hands
- Visit in person if at all possible
- Search the breeder's name and cattery name online for reviews or complaints
- Ask detailed questions about their breeding program, health testing, and kitten care — a real breeder will love talking about it
A Note From Cowgirl Cattery
We know how exciting it is to find your perfect kitten — and we know how devastating it is to be scammed. That is why we are fully transparent about our breeding program, our TICA registration, our health testing, and our process.
When you adopt from Cowgirl Cattery, you are welcome to video call with us, ask as many questions as you like, and meet your kitten before committing. We have nothing to hide — because we have nothing to hide.
If you are ever unsure about a breeder you are considering, feel free to reach out to us. We are happy to help you ask the right questions, even if you end up choosing a different cattery. The most important thing is that you find a healthy, well-loved kitten from someone who genuinely cares.
Keep reading: How to Choose a Reputable Cat Breeder · Why TICA Registration Matters · Questions to Ask a Cat Breeder
Explore Topics
Written by
Cowgirl Cattery
TICA-registered breeder of Ragdoll, Maine Coon, and Bengal kittens in Jacksonville Beach, FL. We share everything we know about cat breeds, kitten care, and responsible breeding — because an informed family makes the best cat family.